Developing a Positive Racial and Ethnic Identity During Adolescence Can Support Healthy Mental and Physical Development and Academic Achievement

Developing a Positive Racial and Ethnic Identity During Adolescence Can Support Healthy Mental and Physical Development and Academic Achievement

During adolescence, we start to form a deeper sense of who we are, what we value, and who we want to be. We become increasingly sensitive to social feedback and better able to think in abstract and complex ways that help us build a deeper sense of self around these questions related to identity. We think more about what it means to be a member of our particular social or cultural group or groups. Healthy development involves creating a positive sense of self and belonging that includes our identity as part of a particular racial as well as ethnic group.

Adolescence In An Important Period for Exploring, Integrating, and Affirming Our Racial and Ethnic Identity

Adolescence is a key window for exploring identity, including our identity as a member of a racial and ethnic group (or groups). Throughout adolescence, youth develop increasing cognitive abilities and social awareness that help them explore more complex identities and build a more nuanced understanding of how people and groups interact. This cognitive and social development often occurs as youth are moving up to middle school and high school–transitions that can introduce diverse new people and experiences. Combined, these changes propel young people to explore the concepts of race and ethnicity and their impact on opportunities and experiences within their immediate community and society at large.

Overall, research on the exploration and development of racial and ethnic identity in adolescence emphasizes its profound impact on adolescents’ social development, mental and physical health, academic achievement, and general well-being.

Developing One’s Racial and Ethnic Identity During Adolescence Has Benefits for Mental and Physical Health

Self esteem

Developing a sense of racial and ethnic identity has been shown to have positive effects on self-esteem during adolescence in youth who identify as Black and African American, Latino and Mexican American, Asian American and Pacific Islander, and Native American.

Mental health

Youth who report feeling a greater sense of belonging to their racial and ethnic groups also report fewer depressive symptoms and decreases in depression over time and those who perceive that their racial and ethnic group is positively regarded by others report lower depression, anxiety, and substance abuse.

Youth who report higher levels of ethnic identity also feel more able to cope with problems, and are less likely to engage in risky health behaviors such as alcohol and drug use.

Adolescents Who Form a Clear Sense of Their Racial and Ethnic Identities May Feel More Engaged In School and More Invested In their Communities

Academic performance

Feelings of belonging to a racial or ethnic group and positive feelings about being a member of a particular racial or ethnic group (or groups) have been linked to better academic performance, increased academic engagement, and positive attitudes about learning and academic achievement in adolescents.

Civic engagement

Developing a stronger racial and ethnic identity in adolescence can also influence young people’s beliefs about the importance of civic engagement to advance their communities and can increase young people’s participation in local and national civic affairs. In Black and Latinx adolescents, more clarity in their racial and ethnic identity by the end of middle school predicted greater beliefs about the importance of engaging with issues affecting their communities.

Helpful behaviors toward others

Black adolescent boys who perceive that their racial and ethnic group is positively regarded by others show higher levels of prosocial behavior such as helping a classmate with homework or trying not to hurt another person’s feelings. Middle school students who engage in and value experiences with people from different cultural groups also report more prosocial behavior like standing up for kids who are bullied or helping those they don’t know that well.

Conversely, when youth who have lower levels of pride in or connection with their ethnic identity experience discrimination, they may be more likely to engage in aggressive or delinquent behavior in late adolescence.

Research Suggests That Having a Stronger Racial and Ethnic Identity During Adolescence Can Protect Against the Negative Impacts of Stress and Race-Based Discrimination

Stressful experiences such as exposure to racial or ethnic discrimination in adolescence can decrease self-esteem and academic achievement and increase symptoms of depression and anxiety. Such discrimination is also linked to externalizing behaviors such as delinquency and aggression, and risky health behaviors such as substance use.

Importantly, research suggests that having a stronger racial and ethnic identity can reduce stress and can also reduce the negative impacts that discrimination can have on academic success and physical health. Having a stronger racial and ethnic identity and higher self-esteem has also been shown to reduce the negative impact of online racial discrimination on Black adolescents’ anxiety levels.

For Black adolescents who experience higher levels of stressful life events (which can include events such as school transition, sickness or loss of a family member, or parental divorce or separation), stronger ethnic identity and activities such as exploring ethnic customs (including special food or music) can protect against negative self-perceptions. Likewise, strong feelings of belonging to a racial and ethnic group or groups can help support expectations of future educational and occupational success.

Physically, developing a strong racial and ethnic identity in adolescence has been shown to lessen the impact of discrimination on the body’s biological stress-response systems and lower elevated cytokine levels (which indicate low-grade inflammation) in young adults who were exposed to discrimination in adolescence.

INSIGHT: Multiracial youth
It is important to note that more and more adolescents identify with more than one racial and ethnic identity, and research suggests that these multiracial youth may face unique challenges in developing a stable sense of their racial and ethnic identity. Two factors that help promote positive outcomes for multiracial youth are support from teachers and parents and positive feelings about one’s racial and ethnic identity. This suggests that schools could support multiracial youth through programs or interventions focused specifically at helping students who identify with more than one racial or ethnic group build positive feelings about their racial and ethnic identity.

Research Suggests Adults Can Help Promote Positive Ethnic-Racial Identity for Adolescents In Multiple Settings

Family environment

When parents help adolescents understand their heritage, including cultural values and traditions, young people are more likely to explore and understand their racial and ethnic identity in adolescence. One school-based intervention to promote racial and ethnic identity was shown to be more effective for youth whose families encouraged them to respect the cultural values and beliefs of their ethnic-cultural background.

School environment

School-based learning practices that promote empathy and support, autonomy and agency, and classroom collaboration have been shown to help middle school students explore and feel pride in their racial and ethnic identity. Youth who report more opportunities to learn about their culture in school are more likely to feel pride and other positive feelings about their group membership and to have better grades. For white youth, school-based learning about racial and ethnic identity can shift attitudes about other racial and ethnic groups and improve their ability to consider the perspectives of others.

POLICY INSIGHT: Intervention that supports positive racial and ethnic identity development
The Identity Project is an eight-week intervention created to help high school students understand concepts of race, ethnicity, culture, and discrimination, and explore their own racial and ethnic identity. Youth who participated in the program were more likely to explore and connect with their racial and ethnic identity, which led to higher self-esteem, lower depressive symptoms, and better grades over the following year. Youth who viewed their racial and ethnic identity as an important part of their overall sense of self benefited the most from the Identity Project. A study testing the Identity Project among adolescents in Italy (approximately 70 percent born in Italy and 30 percent born abroad) showed similar effects on enhancing students’ racial and ethnic identity exploration, suggesting that the Identity Project intervention and adapted versions of its curriculum may prove effective in Europe as well as in the United States.

Conclusion

Overall, research shows the importance of a positive racial and ethnic identity for adolescents and its profound impact on mental and physical health, academic achievement, and general well-being. Developing a positive racial and ethnic identity in adolescence can foster a sense of belonging, help build a positive self-concept, and promote resilience against challenges including discrimination. When educators, parents, and policymakers understand how young people develop their racial and ethnic identity, they can more effectively support young people through positive messages about different racial and ethnic identities, school curricula that teach students about different cultural heritages, mental health services that consider a young person’s racial and ethnic identity, and other programs that promote healthy identity development for adolescents.

Policy and Practice Insights

  • Developing a positive racial and ethnic identity in adolescence can foster a sense of belonging, help build a positive self-concept, and promote resilience against challenges including discrimination.
  • Families can play a role in supporting a young person’s positive racial and ethnic identity development by helping them understand their heritage, cultural values, and traditions. ◆ A review of programs that focus on Black adolescent identity exploration found that these programs can also promote other positive developmental outcomes such as improving parent-child relationships.
  • The positive effects of racial and ethnic identity development on self-esteem among adolescents from diverse ethnic-racial groups are well documented in research; however, the experiences of Native American adolescents are too often missing from research literature. ◆ Learn more about the Center for Native American Youth’s efforts to provide “access to accurate data that reflects the collective thoughts, opinions, experiences, and needs of Native youth from across the country.”
  • Research suggests school-based opportunities are one avenue to promote positive racial and ethnic identity development among adolescents. Participants in a school-based program designed to increase racial and ethnic identity exploration among high school students showed increases in their exploration and resolution of their racial and ethnic identity and, in turn, higher self-esteem, lower depressive symptoms, and better grades over the following year.

This summary represents research related to a diverse range of youth. For specific details about each population of young people in the referenced studies, please check the cited references.

Contact Us

Fill in the box below to ask a question or get more information about STEPS for Youth.